Showing posts with label National Issues. Show all posts
Showing posts with label National Issues. Show all posts

Monday, 7 April 2014

National Population Policy-Targets and Achievements


          India is the second most populous country in the world after China. As per 2011 census, India has a population of about 1.2 billion with an annual growth rate of 1.64%. Our population density which was 117 persons per square km in 1951 has now increased to 382 persons per square km, much higher than 144 persons per sq km for China. In the last decade itself (2001-2011) we have added 18.1 crore people to our population. The increase is almost equal to the population of Brazil (19.07 crores) or Pakistan (18.4 crores) which are 5th and 6th most populous countries of the world. This increase in population absorbs the results of most of our economic achievements and is a major hindrance in increasing the per capita availability of resources. 

The size of population and high growth rate had been a cause of concern even during the British period. The Government had set up a Committee in 1943 to conduct a survey on Indian Health System. The Committee was called The Health Survey and Development Committee. The Committee submitted its report in 1946 in which it devoted one chapter to the problem of increase in population recommending thereafter “the spreading of the knowledge of birth control as far as the limitations imposed by the peculiar circumstances of the country will permit”.
          
          After independence, the matter was taken up in the five year plans wherein family planning was treated as a part of the health programmes. These emphasized family planning to the extent necessary for reducing birth rates to “stabilize the population at a level consistent with the requirement of Indian economy”. National Health policy of 1983 emphasized the need for achieving small family norm through voluntary participation. National Health Policy of 2002 pointed out that efforts for improving health standards of the people have been partly neutralized by rapid growth of population and also that population stabilization measures and general health initiatives when synchronized, maximize the socio-economic well being of the people.    
            
            However, as a need was felt for a National Population Policy, an expert group under Dr.M.S.Swaminathan was set up in 1993 to prepare a draft of the policy. The Committee submitted its report in 1994. The Report basically related population growth to the basic needs, democratic decentralization, gender issues and eco-system. These features were incorporated in the 'Statement on National Population Policy”. 

National Population Policy
            
               National Population Policy was announced in the year 2000. The policy took note of the fact that the growth in population was due to the large size of the population in the reproductive age, high fertility due to inadequate availability of contraception, high wanted fertility due to high infant mortality rates and most of the girls marrying below the age of 18. Some of the important objectives of the policy were as under:
  1. Address the unmet needs for basic reproductive and child health services, supplies and infrastructure.
  2. Make school education up to age 14 free and compulsory, and reduce dropouts at primary and secondary school levels to below 20 percent for both boys and girls. 
  3. Reduce infant mortality rate to below 30 per 1000 live births.
  4. Reduce maternal mortality ratio to below 100 per 100,000 live births.
  5. Achieve universal immunization of children against all vaccine preventable diseases.
  6. Promote delayed marriage for girls, not earlier than age 18 and preferably after 20 years of age.
  7. Achieve 80 percent institutional deliveries and 100 percent deliveries by trained persons.
  8. Achieve universal access to information/counseling, and services for fertility regulation and contraception with a wide basket of choices.
  9. Achieve 100 percent registration of births, deaths, marriage and pregnancy.
  10. Contain the spread of Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome (AIDS), and promote greater integration between the management of reproductive tract infections (RTIs) and sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and the National AIDS Control Organization.
  11. Prevent and control communicable diseases.
  12. Integrate Indian Systems of Medicine (ISM) in the provision of reproductive and child health services, and in reaching out to households.
  13. Promote vigorously the small family norm to achieve replacement levels of TFR.
  14. Bring about convergence in implementation of related social sector programmes so that family welfare becomes a people-centered programme.

Targets and achievements
            
              As per census of 1951, crude birth rate (CBR) was 40.8, Infant Mortality Rate (IMR) was 146, crude death rate 25 and total fertility rate was 6. As per Sample Registration Survey for the year 2012 Crude Birth Rate (CBR) is 21.6; Crude Death Rate (CDR) is 7.0; Infant Mortality Rate (IMR) is 42 and Total Fertility Rate (TFR) is 2.4.  These figures would indicate that the country has made substantive progress in population management since 1951. However, when we see it from the perspective of the targets set by the National Health Policy and National Population Policy we find that our achievements falls short of the targets under the National Population Policy. Similarly, with respect to TFR, National Health Policy targeted replacement levels by 2000 and National Population Policy targeted these levels by 2010, but the figure for the year 2012 is 2.4, which is again much higher than the target. At this rate we may take another 10 years or so to achieve this level of TFR. 
            
                National Population Policy sets the target of achieving a stable population by 2045, that is, after 35 years of achieving the replacement level. The projections appear unrealistic considering the example of China which attained replacement level of total fertility rate in 1990. However, its population is still growing and is expected to achieve peak level only in 2050 after which it will stabilize or gradually decline. Thus, in China, peak level is expected to be achieved after 60 years of achieving replacement level of fertility rates. As India, does not have such a vigorous population control policy as China time taken by India is likely to be much higher.  
      
      Reasons for underachievement
            The above said data indicates the many of the targets set by the National Population Policy have not been achieved. The reasons could be as under:
  1. 1. Unlike China, we have resorted to voluntary participation in population control measures;hence efficacy of these measures would depend on the ability to convince people to have a smaller family. This makes, literacy level a very important factor. As per Census, 2011, Kerala, which has the highest literacy rate of 93.91%, has a very low annual growth rate of .48% while Bihar which has lowest literacy rate of 63.82% has a high annual growth rate of 2.26%.
  2. 2.  Poverty is another important factor. In such families, an additional child is treated as a potential earning hand and hence birth of a child is not discouraged.
  3. 3.  In a number of areas particularly in remote areas, adequate health and birth control facilities are not available without which the people cannot adopt family planning measures.
  4. 4.  Social factors also play an important role. Traditional Indian society prefers early marriage of girls which means that a married woman has more years of reproductive period. This is an important factor in increasing fertility rate and leads to growth in population.

Wednesday, 15 January 2014

Child Labour in India

Child labour can be defined as employment of children in economic activities to such an extent that it adversely affects their physical and mental growth. As per International Labour Organization, “The term “child labour” is often defined as work that deprives children of their childhood, their potential and their dignity, and that is harmful to physical and mental development and refers to the work that is mentally, physically, socially or morally dangerous and harmful to children;  and interferes with their schooling by depriving them of the opportunity to attend school; obliging them to leave school prematurely; or requiring them to attempt to combine school attendance with excessively long and heavy work.”

UNICEF defines Child Labour differently. As per definition of UNICEF, children in the age category 5-11 are considered to be involved in child labour activities if during one week preceding the survey they did at least one hour of economic activity or at least 28 hours of domestic work. For the age group 12 to 14 years the criterion is 14 hours of economic activity or at least 42 hours of economic activity and domestic work combined.

These children work in many sectors including agriculture, manufacturing units, domestic households and other sectors. Some of these occupations are of hazardous nature.  As per Census 2001 there were about 1.26 crores child workers. As per NSSO Survey for 21 major states for the year 2004-05 the number of child workers was about 90.75 lakhs and as per NSSO Survey for these states for the year 2009-10 the number of child workers was about 49.83 lakhs

Factors responsible for child labour

Poverty is the most important factor responsible for prevalence of child labour. A large number of families live below the poverty line. Going by the official estimates for the year 2011-12, the percentage of people below the poverty line is 25.7% for rural areas; 13.7% for urban areas and 21.9% for all India. Number of people below poverty lines as per these estimates is 26.9 crores. Considering the official poverty line  which is Rs.816 per capita per month for rural areas and Rs.1000 per capita per month for urban areas it can be safely presumed that life would be difficult not only for those below poverty line but even for those who are marginally above it. This forces the children from such families to go to work.  

Lack of awareness and education among the lower strata of population is also one of the contributing factors for child labour. People are not aware about of the benefits of education. They feel that sending their children to school would be of no use as education will not change their economic and social status. This coupled with poverty results in a situation in which every child is treated as an additional working hand and is expected to support the family by taking up some remunerative work. Another reason is that a child worker can be engaged at much lower wages than an adult and are hence economical for the businessman particularly in those industries/professions which do not require heavy manual work. In such cases child labour is seen as a cost cutting measure which is facilitated by poor implementation of labour laws.

Impacts of Child Labour

            In the first place the practice is inhuman as it takes away the childhood from the children and hampers their physical and mental growth. As children due to being physically and mentally weak are not to protest in same way as an adult their exploitation is much severe and in some extreme cases the child labour involves trafficking of children, enslavement, separation from families, exposure to hazards and left to fend for themselves in big cities.

            The practice is also harmful for the society as a whole. During his childhood, every child expects to live under care of his parents and acquire knowledge and skills which he can put to use in his adulthood. However, a child labour, on account of devoting his time and energy towards his work does not get opportunities to acquire these skills and is not able to achieve his full potential. This goes against the individual as well as the concept of a welfare state.

            Further, economic system needs educated and trained personnel who are competent to handle various jobs related with diverse economic activities. However, a child labour is not able to acquire education and other training to meet the requirements of diverse and complex nature of jobs coming up due to use of technology in almost every economic activity. Thus child labour adds to the untrained or meagerly trained labour force which is not suitable for growth of economy.

Legal provisions

·    The Constitution of India, in Article 24, provides that no child under the age of 14 years shall be employed to work in a factory, mine or in any other hazardous employment.
·       In Article 39 under the Directive Principles of State Policy, it has been stated that children should be given opportunities and facilities to develop in a healthy manner and in conditions of freedom and dignity.
·   Factories Act prohibits employment of children below the age of 14 years in factories and also regulates the conditions of employment of persons in the age group 15-18 years in these units.
·        The Mines Act prohibits the employment of any person below 18 years in mines.
·    In order to make a comprehensive study on the issue of child labour, the Government formed the Gurupadswamy committee in 1979. The Committee felt that child labour is intrinsically related to poverty and as long as poverty continued, it would be difficult to completely eliminate child labour. Therefore, the best course would be to prohibit employment of children in hazardous areas and to regulate their employment in others. On the basis of the recommendations, the Government enacted the Child Labour (Prohibition & Regulation) Act, 1986.
·     The Act defines a child as a person who has not completed 14 years of age and prohibits employment of such children in hazardous occupations specified in schedule to the Act. Initially the schedule contained 6 occupations and 13 processes. The schedule has been reviewed from time to time. Presently, the list contains 18 occupations and 65 processes.
·     The Government formulated a National Child Policy in 1987. The policy outlined an action plan with three components. First aspect was regarding strict enforcement of the labour laws including the Child Labour Act. This included updating of the list of hazardous occupations by including additional occupations identified as detrimental to the health and safety of the children.  Second aspect was focusing on general development and covering needy people under poverty alleviation programmes. Third aspect was to start projects specifically targeting child labour.
·      The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection) of Children Act of 2000 prohibits procuring or employing a child in any hazardous employment or in bondage and provides punishment for the same.
·        Insertion of Article 21A in the Fundamental Rights and subsequent enactment of the Right of Child to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 provides for free and compulsory education to all children from 6-14 years.
·     National policy for Children adopted by the Government of India in April, 2013 also considers the need for protection of children under situations of labour.  

Programmes for benefit of child labour

·     National Child Labour Project (NCLP) scheme was launched in 9 districts. The scheme envisaged running of special schools for child labour withdrawn from work. In these schools, these children were provided formal/non formal education along with vocational training as well as a cash stipend of Rs.100/- which was increased to Rs.150/- with effect from April, 2011. The scheme is being gradually extended to more and more districts it progressively covered 271 districts. As per annual report of the Ministry of Labour for 2012-13 it is presently running in 266 districts.
·     INDUS (Indo US Child Labour Project) was run in cooperation with the Department of Labour, USA which also covered 21 districts. However, the scheme which was launched in 2000 was only for 8 years and has ended in March, 2009. An estimated 1,03,152 child workers have been rescued and rehabilitated under this project.
·      Another ILO Project named “Converging against Child Labour” has been launched in collaboration with the International Labour Organization and with support of US Department of Labour. The programme covers two districts each in five states (Bihar, Jharkhand, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh and Orissa).
·     Other schemes like Sarv Shiksha Abhiyan, Mid Day Meal Scheme, Integrated Child Protection Scheme, Rural Employment Schemes and other similar schemes are also being implemented for welfare of children and poverty alleviation. All these are expected to make a dent in the problem of Child labour.


Wednesday, 30 October 2013

Disaster Management in India-Institutional Framework

       A terminology developed by the United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction (UNISDR) defines a disaster as “A serious disruption of the functioning of a community or a society involving widespread human, material, economic or environmental losses and impacts, which exceeds the ability of the affected community or society to cope using its own resources.” The Disaster Management Act, 2005 defines a disaster as “a catastrophe, mishap, calamity or grave occurrence in any area, arising from natural or man made causes, or by accident or negligence which results in substantial loss of human sufferings or damage to, and destruction of property, or damage to, or degradation of, environment and is of such nature or magnitude as to be beyond the coping capacity of the affected area”.

            Disasters are divided into two categories. Natural Disaster and Man Made Disasters. Earthquakes, floods, cyclones, tsunami and landslides & avalanches are categorized under natural disasters as these are supposed to be due to natural causes and not directly attributable to human actions although human activities are indirectly responsible for many of them by contributing in the environmental degradation. The second category is the Man-Made Disasters and includes those types of disasters which take place directly due to human actions. These include nuclear disasters, chemical disasters and biological disasters.

            India is a vast country with diverse geographical and climatic conditions and hence different parts are vulnerable to different types of disasters. As per National Disaster Management Policy, 2009, 58.6% of the landmass is prone to earthquakes of varying intensity; over 40 million hectares (12% of land) is prone to floods and river erosion; out of our 7516 Km long coastline, about 5700 Km is prone to cyclones and tsunamis; 68% of the cultivable land is prone to drought and hilly areas are prone to landslides and avalanches. Further, possibility of man made disasters like chemical, biological, radiological and nuclear disasters also exists.

Disaster Management

            Disaster management means a systematic response to a disaster. Earlier the approach to disaster was relief centric and was limited to providing relief to the disaster affected area. For the first time, the tenth five year plan devoted a chapter to disaster management. The approach subsequently changed and pre-empting the disaster, assessing disaster risk and taking preventive measures has also become a part of disaster management. The Disaster Management Act was notified on 26th December 2005 which defines disaster management as “a continuous and integrated process of planning, organising, coordinating and implementing measures which are necessary or expedient for-prevention of danger or threat of any disaster; mitigation or reduction of risk of any disaster or its severity or consequences; capacity building; preparedness to deal with any disaster; prompt response to any threatening disaster situation or disaster; assessing the severity of magnitude of effects of any disaster; evacuation, rescue and relief; and rehabilitation and reconstruction.” The Act provided for a dedicated and institutionalized framework to coordinate various aspects of disaster management. A National Policy on Disaster Management, which provided detailed guidelines on disaster management, was announced in 2009.

National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA)

            The Disaster Management ACT, 2005 provides for setting up of a National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) with the Prime Minister as Chairperson. Apart from him there are members whose number shall not exceed nine. One of these can be nominated as Vice-Chairperson of the Authority. Presently, Sh.M. Shashidhar Reddy, a sitting member of Andhra Pradesh Legislative Assembly is the Vice-Chairman of the Authority.  NDMA is responsible for laying down policies, plans and guidelines for disaster management for ensuring timely and effective response to disaster.

            NDMA is to be assisted by a National Executive Committee which comprises of Secretaries to the Government of India heading various Ministries or Departments having administrative control over Agriculture, Atomic Energy, Defence, drinking water supply, environment and forests, finance, health, power, rural development, science and technology, space, telecommunication, urban development and water resources. Chief of the Integrated Defence Staff of the Chiefs of Staff Committee is also a member of the Executive Committee.

            National Executive Committee is responsible for preparing and updating a National Plan for disaster management. The Plan includes measures to be taken for prevention of disasters or the mitigation of their effects; measures to be taken for the integration of mitigation measures in the development plans; measures to be taken for preparedness and capacity building to effectively respond to any threatening disaster situation or disaster; and defining the roles of various departments in respect of these measures.

State Disaster Management Authority (SDMA)

         The Disaster Management Act 2005 also provides for setting up of Stage Disaster Management Authorities under the Chairpersonship of the Chief Minister.  State Authority is to be assisted by a State Executive Committee under the Chairpersonship of the Chief Secretary of the State. The Committee shall prepare a State Plan which would include assessment of vulnerability of different parts of the State to different forms of disasters; measures to be adopted for prevention and mitigation of disasters; capacity building; and role of departments of State Government. Apart from the planning aspect it is also involved in taking up and supervising relief and rescue operations at the time of disaster and in disseminating information about any impending disaster.

District Disaster Management Authority (DDMA)

           The structure of disaster management institutions goes down to the district level where the responsibility is given to DDMA which is headed by the Collector/District Magistrate with elected representative of the local authority as co-chairperson. DDMA will act as the planning, coordinating and implementing body for disaster management at the district level. It will prepare the District Plan for disaster management in accordance with instructions by NDMA and SDMA. The DDMA will also ensure that the guidelines    for prevention, mitigation, preparedness and response measures laid down by the NDMA and the SDMA are followed by all    the Departments of  the State Government at the District level and the local            authorities in the District.
                           
Local Authority

             For the purpose of disaster management, local authorities would include Panchayati Raj institutions and those agencies which control and manage civic services. These bodies are required to ensure capacity building of their employees for managing disasters and carrying out relief and reconstruction activities in the affected areas.

National Institute of Disaster Management (NIDM)

       Capacity building is an important aspect of disaster management. This requires developing human resources to handle disaster management work and undertake studies and research on the subject. Disaster Management Act gives this mandate to the National Institute of Disaster Management. The institute was formed as National Centre for Disaster Management (NCDM) in 1995 but was re-designated  as National Institute of Disaster Management in 2005 after the enacting of the Disaster Management Act. The institute is headed by the Union Home Minister and Vice-Chairman, NDMA also acts as the Vice-President of the Institute. Day to day works are looked after by the Executive Director. The institute has five divisions i.e Geo-Hazard Division; Hydro-Met Hazard Division; Policy Planning and Cross Cutting Issues Division; Response Division; and Administrative and Finance Division.
National Disaster Response Force(NDRF)

            NDRF was constituted in 2006 with 8 battalions drawn from the paramilitary forces. Presently it has strength of 10 battalions. General superintendence of the force vests in NDMA and the force is headed by the Director General of NDRF and Civil Defence. These battalions are positioned at different locations to provide timely response to disaster situations and are available to State Governments at the time of need. The force provides specialized response during disasters, is pro-actively deployed in impending disaster situations, imparts training to state disaster response force personnel and conducts programmes for creating awareness and community capacity building.

Integrated Data Resource Network(IDRN) 

            Integrated Data Resource Network is a database in the electronic form maintained by the Ministry of Home Affairs. The data enlists inventory of equipments and human resources relevant to disaster management. Organizations related with the work update the inventory of equipments, skilled human resources and critical supplies for emergency response. Idea is to make available the information on availability of equipments and human resources required to combat any emergency situation. This database also helps the policy makers to assess the level of preparedness for specific vulnerabilities.

Other Institutional arrangements
  • Cabinet Committee on Management of Natural Calamities (CCMNC) has been constituted to oversee all aspects relating to the management of natural calamities.
  • National Calamity Contingency Fund (NCCF) was created in 2000-01 by the  Govt of India with a corpus fund of Rs.500 crores with an objective of providing assistance to disaster affected states. The fund was replenished with the National Calamity Contingent Duty on certain items such as tobacco products etc. and was operated through a High Level Committee (HLC) which had Finance Minister, as Chairman and the Home Minister, Agriculture Minister & Deputy Chairman, Planning Commission as members. Since 2010, this find has been merged with National Disaster Response Fund (NDRF) which is also operated by a High Level Committee with similar composition.
  • Armed Forces are called upon to assist the civil administration only when the situation is beyond their coping capability. In practice, however, the armed forces form an important part of the Government’s response capacity and are immediate responders in all serious disaster situations. They have played a major role in emergency support functions like communication, search and rescue operations, medical facilities and transportation.
  • Central Paramilitary forces also play a key role at the time of immediate response to disasters. Besides contributing to the NDRF, they are also required to develop adequate disaster management capability within their own forces and respond to disasters which may occur in the areas where they are posted.
  • State Police and Fire Services are crucial immediate responders to disasters are required to improve their response capabilities.
  • Civil Defence Act has been amended in 2009 to bring disaster management in the area of operation of civil defence agencies.
  • International agencies also play a role in disaster management. UNDP alongwith NDMA took up Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) and Urban Risk Reduction programmes. World Bank is associated with National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) being taken up in Andhra Pradesh and Orissa. Red Cross Society also provides valuable support during relief operations. 

Monday, 14 October 2013

Regionalism

Regionalism literally means connected with or specific to a geographical region. In politics, it means a political ideology focused on the interests of a particular region. India is a large and diverse country. Different languages and cultures have flourished in its different parts which were supported by regional kingdoms which came up in these regions. These factors gave each region a separate linguistic and cultural identity resulting in growth of a feeling of regional nationalism. This feeling coupled with the disparity in economic development resulted in development of politics on regional basis and consequently led to growth of regional political parties. While growth of regionalism and regional politics should be welcomed for the purpose of bringing same levels of economic development in all parts of the country and for preserving its cultural diversity due care should be taken so that the regional identity does not overshadow national identity.

Growth of regional politics

           Earliest political movement having regional traits was the demand for a separate “Dravid Nadu” in 1920s which was raised by non Brahman Tamil politicians. Although, the demand for separate Dravid Nadu was later dropped, the movement resulted in growth of Dravid Munnetra Kazhgam (DMK) as the major political force in Tamilnadu. However, regional affiliations were not so strong in the pre-independence era and during the freedom struggle. This was because the freedom fighters had a common enemy in the British rule which was supposedly responsible for all the problems of the people and it was felt that all the problems can be solved if the British leave the country.  During this period, even the Indian National Congress was in support of formation of states on linguistic basis. In Nagpur session in 1920, the Indian National Congress accepted in principle the creation of linguistic states and provincial committees of the Congress were formed on linguistic basis. However, after independence, the Congress government started having second thoughts about the idea considering it to have adverse impact on national integration.

            After independence, the first demand for creating a state on linguistic basis came from erstwhile Madras Presidency where the Telugu speaking people started an agitation for creation of a separate state. Potti Sreeramlu lost his life on 15th December, 1952, after 52 days of a fast-unto-death in support of this demand. This led mass protests which forced the Government to accede to the demand. Later a State Reorganization Commission was appointed. On the basis of its recommendations, 14 states and 3 Union territories were created, mostly on linguistic considerations. Since then, many more states have been created from time to time. The considerations have been either linguistic; cultural; economic or a combination of these. Recently, the Union Government has taken a decision to create a separate state of Telengana out of the state of Andhra Pradesh.

Increase in consciousness of regional identities has led to growth of regional political parties and regionalism has firmly entrenched itself as a political reality in Indian scenario. While some of these parties have clearly pronounced their regional ideology, others though not so explicit have modeled their policies and programmes so as to suit a particular state or geographical region. In the last few decades, regional parties have considerably strengthened their position. A number of states like UP, Bihar, West Bengal, Tamil Nadu and Punjab are either being ruled by regional parties or by coalitions in which the regional party is the major partner. Growth of these parties has seriously dented the prospects of the national parties. In the last two decades none of the national parties has been able to form a national government on its own and has to resort to alliances and coalitions. This has brought in the era of coalition politics. National parties have accepted the situation and now attach great importance to their coalition partners who at times appear to have an upper hand.

Reasons for growth of regional tendencies

  • Regionalism is inherent in India because of its cultural and linguistic diversity. Each region has its own history and culture. People of these regions take pride in their culture and language and want to preserve and support it. 
  • National political parties have failed to understand the aspirations of people. Their leaders laid stress on nationalism and national integration without integrating these concepts with the cultural diversity of the country. This alienated those people who wanted their language and culture to prosper.
  • National parties have not given due considerations to their state units.  Usually, state leadership is selected keeping in view the politics at the national level. Most of the times, election of the leader by MLAs is a mere formality, the decision having already been made by the central leadership.
  • Even after that, the state units of these parties do not have reasonable independence. Regional interests are sometimes compromised for political expediency in some other part of the country. This projects state leaders of national parties in poor light vis-à-vis the leaders of regional parties who are not subject to any control and also do not have any political compulsion arising out of political expediency in other areas.
  • Sometimes policies of the National government fuel regionalism. People in Southern states have been apprehensive of Hindi being imposed upon them. This was one of the factors for the growth of regional parties in these regions.
  • During the course of development, some areas got preference, while others got neglected. People from these areas felt that the situation can improve if people from their region are at the helm of affairs.
  • There has been inter-region movement of people. Sometimes the original inhabitants of the region feel that their domination is being threatened by the immigrants from other regions.
  • Some of the local leaders have exploited the feelings of the people to gain political power. Being localized, these people also have advantage of taking up the issue of only a particular region and hence can be more vocal in their tirades.

 Positive impacts
  •  By way of supporting local language and culture, it helps to preserve the cultural diversity of the country.
  • Its greatest benefit is in the field of education. Imparting primary education in the local language has greatly helped in increasing literacy levels.
  • States have also adopted their local language in their functioning which has made the common man more comfortable and the administration more people friendly.
  • People from less developed regions have always alleged that they are being discriminated against in the matters related to development. This grudge is      removed when local people govern the region.

Negative impacts
  • The world in which we presently live has considerably changed in the last few decades. Improvements in technology and liberalization have opened up communities and regions. Inter region interactions have substantially increased and no region can survive in isolation. Regionalism, while laying stress on regional aspects tends to overlook this important factor.
  • There is a very thin line between respect for one’s culture and belief in superiority of one’s culture over the other. Experience has shown that this thin line has often been violated due to exhortations from various groups having a narrow and sectarian approach.
  • In its extreme form, ideology of regionalism has resulted in separatist movements like ULFA movement in Assam, Khalistan movement in Punjab and other separatist movements in north east.
  • At the political front, growth of regionalism has brought in coalition politics. This has diluted the ideological base of the political parties and also affected the functioning of the Government.
  • Sphere of influence of some of the regional parties is coterminous with the areas of domination of a particular caste. In such cases the ideology of these parties becomes casteist in nature and is not conducive to social integration.
  • Regionalism increases the magnitude of disputes between states because of the emotive aspect which comes with regional nationalism.

Conclusion

       Every concept is as good or as bad as the people implementing it. Regionalism can play a vital role in preserving the cultural diversity of the country and can also be of great help in removing regional disparities in development. However, if uncontrolled, it can also become the cause of national disintegration. The best way would be to keep a balanced approach in such matters so that there is minimal conflict of interests between the region and the nation.

Friday, 27 September 2013

Urbanization


            An urban settlement differs from a rural one in a number of ways. Not only are the urban settlements bigger they usually indicate a higher standard of living. The difference is also in the nature of economic activities. In a rural settlement, most of the population is engaged in agriculture or allied activities i.e. in primary sector while in an urban centre most of the population is engaged in activities like manufacturing and services i.e. in secondary and tertiary sector. Different countries have adopted different criteria to distinguish between rural and urban centres. Census of India, 2011 defines an urban unit as one having a Municipality, Municipal Corporation or a Cantonment Board; or all other places having a population of at least 5000, 75% of the main male workers being engaged in non agricultural pursuits and a population density of at least 400 per sq. km.

            Urbanization is the movement of people from rural to urban areas resulting in a concentration of population in urban areas or cities. In economic terms, it is also the movement of people from agriculture based communities to other communities which are generally larger and taking up diverse economic activities like Government related activities, trade, manufacturing and allied activities. Urbanization is a multi dimensional process. The changes are not only geographical but involve economic and social dimensions. This further result in changes in the migrant’s believes attitudes and behaviour patterns.

Urbanization in India

            Urbanization in India has a fairly long history dating back to the periods of Indus Valley Civilizaion. Urban centres grew up in various periods of history including the medieval period. During the British period urbanization was primarily for governmental requirements and for facilitating trade outside India. However, these centres were limited and most of the population resided in villages. As per 1901 census only 10.86% of the population lived in cities. As per 1951 census, the figure was 17.29% while in the year 2001, 27.81% of the population lived in urban areas. Census of 2011 puts the percentage of urban population as 31.16%. These figures indicate that the pace of urbanization has increased after independence. While in first half of the last century, the increase in urban population was only 6.43%, the corresponding figure for the second half of the century was about 10.52%. The speed has been even faster in this century as an increase of 3.35% has been registered in a single decade. In this decade, for the first time since Independence, the absolute increase in population is more in urban areas that in rural areas. The growth rate of population in rural areas as compared to 2001 census has decreased from 18.1% to 12.2% (a decrease of 5.9%) while in the urban areas the growth rate of population has increased from 31.5% to 31.8% (an increase of .3%). Although, some of this increase could be due to more settlements being categorized as urban, nonetheless, these figures quite clearly indicate the rapid pace of urbanization in India.

Causes of urbanization

            Urbanization involves movement of people from rural to urban areas. This can be of two types. First type is due to the ‘pull’ factor in which the people are attracted towards the city for a better quality of life. Second type is the ‘push’ factor in which the people move from villages to cities to avoid the poor quality of life in villages. Though, migration from the village to cities is usually a combination of both these types in varying proportions, the ‘push’ factor has been dominant in the Indian context.

            During the 20th century and particularly in the decades after independence the country witnessed a sharp increase in population. Population of India which was about 23.86 crores in 1901 increased to about 36.11 crores in 1951; 84.64 crores in 1991; 102.87 crores in 2001 and 121.02 crores in 2011. Thus progressive growth rate over 1901 population was 51.47% in 1951; 255.05% in 1991; 331.52% in 2001 and 407.64% in 2011. As most of the population was and still is dependent upon agriculture, this created pressure on land. The increase in population decreased the size of average agricultural land holdings and a large number of them were reduced to such a level that these could not support a family. This forced the farmer to look for other employment opportunities. Indian rural population has also a sizeable number of non-farmers. These included village artisans, landless labourers and other workers who also started looking outside for better employment opportunities. However, these opportunities were not available in sufficient numbers in villages or nearby towns. In such a case, the beleaguered rural population had no option but to migrate to some industrial centre in search of employment.   
            Caste system is also one of the reasons for this migration. Members of the lower caste, apart from being economically deprived section in rural India are also socially harassed lot. People from this community did not have any incentive to live in villages. Urban centres gave them independence at least from the social degradation they suffered in their villages. Hence, these people moved out to the urban centres at the first available opportunity. This kind of migration due to ‘push’ factor is driven by non availability of opportunities in rural areas, possibility of getting a job in urban areas and possibilities of a better quality of life. As cities offer more possibility of getting a job in comparison to the smaller towns, such migrants avoid small towns and come straight to cities.

Some migration has also taken place due to the ‘pull’ factor. In earlier days, land was source of wealth and status. However, since the beginning of the last century and particularly after independence, there has been substantial growth in trade and industry. These activities are usually carried out in urban areas. Consequently, many members of the landed gentry shifted their economic activities to these more profitable areas and shifted to cities. Some people also migrated due to availability of better infrastructure in cities. These included those people who were well off in villages but wanted a better quality of life and better education for their children.

Impact of urbanization

            Urbanization is usually seen as an indicator of development as it indicates that more and more people are engaged in secondary or tertiary economic activities. Unfortunately, urbanization in India has been unsystematic and lopsided. Industrialization has not been evenly spread throughout the country resulting in a few industrialized pockets. Obviously these have large requirements of workers and hence attract sizeable number of migrants from other unindustrialized areas. This coupled with the push factor from the villages resulted in an exodus from the villages. As no systematic effort was made to develop industries in smaller towns which could provide employment to these people, this group landed in cities which were not geared up to provide even basic facilities to these people. First requirement of these migrants was accommodation and when the city could not meet their demands, slums came up in cities, in which people lived in extremely pathetic conditions.
As per draft mission document of National Urban Livelihood Mission under the Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation, population residing in urban slums has been estimated at about 93 million. As per data provided by Census, 2011, 3% of the urban population does not have an exclusive room for living, while 32% live in one room house.  About 29.4% of the urban population does not have access to tap water and 18.6% do not have latrine facility within the house. 7.3% of urban population still does not have access to electricity. This aspect of urbanization can hardly be accepted and brings with itself a host of economic, social and environmental problems. 

The migration which takes place due to ‘pull’ factor mainly comprises of people who though well off in villages, visualize better infrastructure and facilities in cities and move there for a better quality of life. This kind of migration does not have any adverse impact on cities but this drains the village of the skilled and educated population. 

The impact of urbanization has also been social. Cities comprise of population from different regions having different cultural backgrounds. The migrants and the original inhabitants are mutually affected by the culture and way of life of each other. People become more open, tolerant and broad minded in their views resulting in the development of a cosmopolitan culture. Though tensions sometimes do arise between various groups but tolerance and mutual interdependence soon brings the life to normal.

Solutions

            Development of infrastructure in cities is one aspect of the solution. However, administration of the cities has been entrusted to municipalities, which do not have the expertise or the resources to deal with the rapidly changing scenario. There is hardly any stress on long term planning. Their financial powers are also limited as the sources on which they can levy tax are very limited. This will have to be looked into by the Government because if the cities are to improve, their local governments will have to rise to the occasion.


However, even if this is achieved, it will not be of much use unless the conditions which ‘push’ people to migrate to cities continue to exist. Therefore apart from developing infrastructure in cities it is also important that alternative employment is generated in the villages itself. This could be done by developing agriculture based small scale industries. Further, industries making use of local resources and expertise should be developed in small towns. This would help these towns to absorb those people who could not gain employment in villages. This would ensure a more even development as well as a better quality of life in both rural and urban areas. 

Friday, 20 September 2013

Capital Punishment: Should it be retained or abolished

Recent death penalty to all the four accused in the 16th December 2012 gang rape case has again raised the debate about the death penalty. Amnesty International, in its press release on 13th September 2013, while condemning the crime committed by these people stated that death penalty is not the answer. It further stated that death penalty is not a solution of the problem but only short term revenge and also that death penalty is not a deterrent for any crime. The present article tries to present an analysis of the subject.

            Punishment can be defined as suffering, loss, pain or penalty inflicted upon an individual by a legal authority, as a consequence of certain acts of commission and omission. Punishment has two aspects. First is ‘utilitarian’ in which punishment is used as a tool for increasing happiness of the society by pointing out to the criminal the wrongfulness of his crime as well presenting the punishment as a deterrent to both the criminal and the society for not repeating the crime. Second aspect is ‘retributive’ which serves as a consolation to the aggrieved or his kin that the criminal has been adequately punished.  Capital punishment is the ultimate punishment in which life of a criminal is taken away by a legal authority under a process established by the law.

International Scenario


            Although, UN “Universal Declaration of Human Rights” does not say anything explicitly about death penalty, Article 5 of the said declaration prohibits torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.  Activists have been arguing that death penalty is cruel and inhuman and hence covered under this article. The Second Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1989, provides for the total abolition of the death penalty except in times of war or imminent threat of war. Protocol No. 6 to the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms ["European Convention on Human Rights"] 1982 and The Protocol to the American Convention on Human Rights to Abolish the Death Penalty, 1990 provide for abolishing death penalties except in times of war.  Protocol No. 13 to the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, 2002, provides for the abolition of the death penalty in all circumstances, including time of war or of imminent threat of war. As per report of Amnesty International for year 2012, 97 countries have abolished capital punishment completely, while 8 have retained it only in exceptional circumstances such as military law and wartime crimes. 35 countries have abolished it in practice as they are believed to have a policy or practice of not executing people. 58 countries have retained the penalty for certain crimes like murder.

Indian Legal position
Article 21 of the Constitution of India provides that “No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law.” Thus, power to award capital punishment is inherent in the Constitution. However, judicial pronouncements state that the penalty has to be imposed only in special circumstances. In Bachan Singh Vs. State of Punjab, the Supreme Court held that punishment was to be only in the “rarest of rare” cases. However, defining ‘rarest of rare’ has been left to the discretion of the Court though some guidelines were set which included consideration of both the aggravating and mitigating factors leading to the crime. In Machchi Singh vs. State of Punjab, the Apex Court, while accepting that the death penalty can be imposed in some cases, has opined that it should not be so in every case but only in exceptional circumstances. However, the definition of the ‘rarest of rare’ has differed from case to case.

Arguments for abolition

       Arguments for abolition of death penalty have centred on human rights and wrongful executions i.e. those cases in which there had been an error in handing out this punishment. Following arguments have been put forward for abolishing death penalty:
  • Capital punishment is the ultimate denial of human rights and right to life.
  • It is cruel, inhuman and degrading punishment in whatever form it is given. Like torture, it is extreme physical and mental assault on an individual and cannot be justified.
  • The penalty is discriminatory and is used disproportionately against deprived and marginalized sections of the society as well as for eliminating political opponents.
  • The penalty cannot be reversed. As there is always a possibility of error in the judicial process, there is always a possibility of execution of an innocent.
  • It denies the criminal an opportunity to amend himself and also denies possibility of rehabilitation and reconciliation.
  • It is a symptom of culture of violence and not a solution to it.
  • There are no clear-cut evidences showing that death penalty acts as a deterrent.  Most of the murders are committed either in a state of rage or under the belief that the criminal would escape from the law and the thought of deterrent does not come to the mind of criminal while committing the murder.  

Arguments for retention
  • Arguments for abolishing death have questioned the state’s authority to take the life of the person; right of the State has being the primary target of such activism. However, most of the crimes are against individuals which due to legal procedure are taken up by the State. The demand for abolition of death penalty ignores the hardships and suffering of the victim.
  • Death penalty, in no way means denying a fair trial to any accused, which is a must in every judicial system.
  • Right to life in respect of a criminal has to be balanced with the right of the victim to get appropriate justice.
  • In most of the cases of death penalty, the life of victim has been taken away by the criminal. In a number of cases, this is without any provocation or excuse. Protecting the life of a criminal in such cases would place him at an advantageous position as compared to the victim. It would appear that the state or the law, while failing to save an innocent citizen is saving the criminal.
  • Since ancient ages   punishment has been used as a deterrent for crime. Conclusive studies are lacking because such studies centre on the criminals who have committed the crime. The studies do not consider those people who have deterred from crime due to fear of punishment.
  • An important reason for the death penalty not being a sufficient deterrent is that it is used very sparingly. In India, Ajmal Kasaab was executed in 2012 and and Afzal Guru 2013. Before them execution the last person to be executed was Dhananjoy Chaterjee in 2004 who was convicted in Hetal Parekh rape and murder case. There were no executions in the years in between although combined number of heinous crimes during these years was in lakhs. In 2012 alone there were more than 34000 murders but total number of death penalties awarded during the year was about 78. These penalties are awarded by trial courts which slowly get diluted as the convict appeals in higher courts. Actual execution during the year was only one that of Ajmal Kasaab on 21st November 2012.  The number of actual executions is too miniscule to act as a potential deterrent.
  • It has been criticized as a symptom of violence but it comes only into play after an act of extreme violence by the criminal which should justifiably be punished.
  • Abolition of death penalty has an inherent danger of compassion taking a leading role in the entire criminal justice. This would tilt the balance in favour of the criminal. While on one hand this dilutes the deterrent aspect of criminal justice, on the other, the victim or his relatives may resort to punishing the criminal themselves by taking the law into their own hands.
Should India retain or abolish capital punishment?

            Continuation or retention of death penalty in a country depends on the circumstances of the country. As per data available with National Crime Records Bureau, number of total crimes registered under IPC has increased from 6, 01,964 in 1953 to 23,87,188 in 2012, thereby showing an increase of about 296%. Similarly, number of murders has increased from 9802 in 1953 to 34,434 in 2012 and showing an increase of about 251%. However, highest increase has been in the cases of rape. NCRB started collecting data about this crime since 1971 when the number was 2487. In 2012, the figure is 24, 293, thereby showing an increase of 902%.
One reason that has often been attributed to the spiraling crime is that our law is soft on criminals. The stress has been more on the reforming the criminal rather than punishing the criminal. This aspect adversely affects the deterrent effect of the punishment. The data from National Crime Record Bureau does not make out a case for abolition of death penalty. On contrary, it reflects the need to be stricter in awarding the penalty as well as considering the option of making more crimes punishable by death. First right to a life of dignity must go to a law abiding citizen and right to life of the innocent must take precedence over the right to life of a criminal. If otherwise, it would render the state useless and would give rise to Vigilante justice in which individuals would themselves take upon the responsibility of dispensing criminal justice.